Tech-invite3GPPspaceIETF RFCsSIP
929190898887868584838281807978777675747372717069686766656463626160595857565554535251504948474645444342414039383736353433323130292827262524232221201918171615141312111009080706050403020100
in Index   Prev   Next

RFC 7945

Information-Centric Networking: Evaluation and Security Considerations

Pages: 38
Informational
Errata
Part 2 of 2 – Pages 21 to 38
First   Prev   None

Top   ToC   RFC7945 - Page 21   prevText

4. Evaluation Tools

Since ICN is an emerging area, the community is in the process of developing effective evaluation environments, including releasing open-source implementations, simulators, emulators, and testbeds. To date, none of the available evaluation tools can be seen as the one and only community reference evaluation tool. Furthermore, no single environment supports all well-known ICN approaches, as we describe below, hindering the direct comparison of the results obtained for different ICN approaches. The subsections that follow review the currently publicly available ICN implementations, simulators, and experimental facilities. An updated list of the available evaluation tools will be maintained at the ICNRG Wiki page: <https://trac.tools.ietf.org/group/irtf/trac/ wiki/IcnEvaluationAndTestbeds>

4.1. Open-Source Implementations

The Named Data Networking (NDN) project has open-sourced a software reference implementation of the architecture and protocol called NDN (http://named-data.net). NDN is available for deployment on various operating systems and includes C and Java libraries that can be used to build applications. CCN-lite (http://www.ccn-lite.net) is a lightweight implementation of the CCN protocol that supports most of the key features of CCNx and is interoperable with CCNx. CCN-lite implements the core CCN logic in about 1000 lines of code, so it is ideal for classroom work and course projects as well as for quickly experimenting with CCN extensions. For example, Baccelli et al. use CCN-lite on top of the RIOT operating system to conduct experiments over an IoT testbed [Baccelli14].
Top   ToC   RFC7945 - Page 22
   PARC is offering CCN source code under various licensing schemes,
   please see <http://www.ccnx.org> for details.

   The PURSUIT project (http://www.fp7-pursuit.eu) has open-sourced its
   Blackhawk publish-subscribe (Pub/Sub) implementation for Linux and
   Android; more details are available at
   <https://github.com/fp7-pursuit/blackadder>.  Blackadder uses the
   Click modular router for ease of development.  The code distribution
   features a set of tools, test applications, and scripts.  The POINT
   project (http://www.point-h2020.eu) is currently maintaining
   Blackadder.

   The 4WARD and SAIL projects have open-sourced software that
   implements different aspects of NetInf, e.g., the NetInf URI format
   and HTTP and UDP convergence layer, using different programming
   languages.  The Java implementation provides a local caching proxy
   and client.  Further, an OpenNetInf prototype is available as well as
   a hybrid host-centric and information-centric network architecture
   called the Global Information Network (GIN), a browser plug-in and
   video-streaming software.  See <http://www.netinf.org/open-source>
   for more details.

4.2. Simulators and Emulators

Simulators and emulators should be able to capture faithfully all features and operations of the respective ICN architecture(s) and any limitations should be openly documented. It is essential that these tools and environments come with adequate logging facilities so that one can use them for in-depth analysis as well as debugging. Additional requirements include the ability to support medium- to large-scale experiments, the ability to quickly and correctly set various configurations and parameters, as well as to support the playback of traffic traces captured on a real testbed or network. Obviously, this does not even begin to touch upon the need for strong validation of any evaluated implementations.

4.2.1. ndnSIM

The Named Data Networking (NDN) project (http://named-data.net) has developed ndnSIM [ndnSIM] [ndnSIM2]; this is a module that can be plugged into the ns-3 simulator (https://www.nsnam.org) and supports the core features of NDN. One can use ndnSIM to experiment with various NDN applications and services as well as components developed for NDN such as routing protocols and caching and forwarding strategies, among others. The code for ns-3 and ndnSIM is openly available to the community and can be used as the basis for implementing ICN protocols or applications. For more details, see <http://ndnsim.net/2.0/>.
Top   ToC   RFC7945 - Page 23

4.2.2. ccnSIM

ccnSim [ccnSim] is a CCN-specific simulator that was specially designed to handle forwarding of a large number of CCN-chunks (http://www.infres.enst.fr/~drossi/index.php?n=Software.ccnSim). ccnSim is written in C++ for the OMNeT++ simulation framework (https://omnetpp.org). Other CCN-specific simulators include the CCN Packet-Level Simulator [CCNPL] and CCN-Joker [Cianci12]. CCN-Joker emulates in user space all basic aspects of a CCN node (e.g., handling of Interest and Data packets, cache sizing, replacement policies), including both flow and congestion control. The code is open source and is suitable for both emulation-based analyses and real experiments. Finally, Cabral et al. [MiniCCNx] use container- based emulation and resource isolation techniques to develop a prototyping and emulation tool.

4.2.3. Icarus Simulator

The Icarus simulator [ICARUS] focuses on caching in ICN and is agnostic with respect to any particular ICN implementation. The simulator is implemented in Python, uses the Fast Network Simulator Setup tool [Saino13], and is available at <http://icarus-sim.github.io>. Icarus has several caching strategies implemented, including among others ProbCache [Psaras12], node- centrality-based caching [Chai12], and hash-route-based caching [HASHROUT]. ProbCache [Psaras12] is taking a resource management view on caching decisions and approximates the available cache capacity along the path from source to destination. Based on this approximation and in order to reduce caching redundancy across the path, it caches content probabilistically. According to [Chai12], the node with the highest "betweenness centrality" along the path from source to destination is responsible for caching incoming content. Finally, [HASHROUT] calculates the hash function of a content's name and assigns contents to caches of a domain according to that. The hash space is split according to the number of caches of the network. Then, upon subsequent requests, and based again on the hash of the name included in the request, edge routers redirect requests to the cache assigned with the corresponding hash space. [HASHROUT] is an off-path caching strategy; in contrast to [Psaras12] and [Chai12], it requires minimum coordination and redirection overhead. In its latest update, Icarus also includes implementation of the "Satisfied Interest Table" (SIT) [Sourlas15]. The SIT points in the direction where content has been sent recently. Among other benefits, this enables information resilience in case of network fragmentation (i.e., content can still
Top   ToC   RFC7945 - Page 24
   be found in neighbor caches or in users' devices) and inherently
   supports user-assisted caching (i.e., P2P-like content distribution).

   Tortelli et al. [ICNSIMS] provide a comparison of ndnSIM, ccnSim, and
   Icarus.

4.3. Experimental Facilities

An important consideration in the evaluation of any kind of future Internet mechanism lies in the characteristics of that evaluation itself. Central to the assessment of the features provided by a novel mechanism is the consideration of how it improves over already existing technologies, and by "how much". With the disruptive nature of clean-slate approaches generating new and different technological requirements, it is complex to provide meaningful results for a network-layer framework, in comparison with what is deployed in the current Internet. Thus, despite the availability of ICN implementations and simulators, the need for large-scale environments supporting experimental evaluation of novel research is of prime importance to the advancement of ICN deployment. Different experimental facilities have different characteristics and capabilities, e.g., having low cost of use, reproducible configuration, easy-to-use tools, and available background traffic, and being sharable.

4.3.1. Open Network Lab (ONL)

An example of an experimental facility that supports CCN is the Open Network Lab [ONL] that currently comprises 18 extensible gigabit routers and over a 100 computers representing clients and is freely available to the public for running CCN experiments. Nodes in ONL are preloaded with CCNx software. ONL provides a graphical user interface for easy configuration and testbed setup as per the experiment requirements, and also serves as a control mechanism, allowing access to various control variables and traffic counters. Further, it is also possible to run and evaluate CCN over popular testbeds [PLANETLAB] [EMULAB] [DETERLAB] [OFELIA] by directly running, for example, the CCNx open-source code [Salsano13] [Carofiglio13] [Awiphan13] [Bernardini14]. Also, the Network Experimentation Programming Interface (NEPI) [NEPI] is a tool developed for controlling and managing large-scale network experiments. NEPI can be used to control and manage large-scale CCNx experiments, e.g., on PlanetLab [Quereilhac14].
Top   ToC   RFC7945 - Page 25

4.3.2. POINT Testbed

The POINT project is maintaining a testbed with 40 machines across Europe, North America (Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT)), and Japan (National Institute of Information and Communications Technology (NICT)) interconnected in a topology containing one Topology Manager and one rendezvous node that handle all publish/subscribe and topology formation requests [Parisis13]. All machines run Blackadder (see Section 4.1). New nodes can join, and experiments can be run on request.

4.3.3. CUTEi: Container-Based ICN Testbed

NICT has also developed a testbed used for ICN experiments [Asaeda14] comprising multiple servers located in Asia and other locations. Each testbed server (or virtual machine) utilizes a Linux kernel- based container (LXC) for node virtualization. This testbed enables users to run applications and protocols for ICN in two experimentation modes using two different container designs: 1. application-level experimentation using a "common container" and 2. network-level experimentation using a "user container." A common container is shared by all testbed users, and a user container is assigned to one testbed user. A common container has a global IP address to connect with other containers or external networks, whereas each user container uses a private IP address and a user space providing a closed networking environment. A user can login to his/her user containers using SSH with his/her certificate, or access them from PCs connected to the Internet using SSH tunneling. This testbed also implements an "on-filesystem cache" to allocate caching data on a UNIX filesystem. The on-filesystem cache system accommodates two kinds of caches: "individual cache" and "shared cache." Individual cache is accessible for one dedicated router for the individual user, while shared cache is accessible for a set of routers in the same group to avoid duplicated caching in the neighborhood for cooperative caching.

5. Security Considerations

This document does not impact the security of the Internet, but Section 3 outlines security and privacy concerns that might affect a deployment of a future ICN approach.
Top   ToC   RFC7945 - Page 26

6. Informative References

[4WARD6.1] Ohlman, B., et al., "First NetInf Architecture Description", 4WARD Project Deliverable D-6.1, April 2009. [4WARD6.3] Ahlgren, B., et al., "NetInf Evaluation", 4WARD Project Deliverable D-6.3, June 2010. [Arlitt97] Arlitt, M. and C. Williamson, "Internet web servers: workload characterization and performance implications", IEEE/ACM Transactions on Networking, vol. 5, pp. 631-645, DOI 10.1109/90.649565, 1997. [Asaeda14] Asaeda, H., Li, R., and N. Choi, "Container-Based Unified Testbed for Information-Centric Networking", IEEE Network, vol. 28, no. 6, pp. 60-66, DOI 10.1109/MNET.2014.6963806, 2014. [Awiphan13] Awiphan, S., et al., "Video streaming over content centric networking: Experimental studies on PlanetLab", Proc. Computing, Communications and IT Applications Conference (ComComAp), IEEE, DOI 10.1109/ComComAp.2013.6533602, 2013. [Baccelli14] Baccelli, E., et al., "Information Centric Networking in the IoT: Experiments with NDN in the Wild", Proceedings of the 1st international conference on Information-centric networking (ICN '14), ACM, DOI 10.1145/2660129.2660144, 2014. [Barabasi99] Barabasi, A. and R. Albert, "Emergence of Scaling in Random Networks", Science, vol. 286, no. 5439, pp. 509-512, DOI 10.1126/science.286.5439.509, 1999. [Barford98] Barford, P. and M. Crovella, "Generating representative web workloads for network and server performance evaluation", in ACM SIGMETRICS '98 / PERFORMANCE '98, pp. 151-160, DOI 10.1145/277851.277897, 1998. [Barford99] Barford, P., Bestavros, A., Bradley, A., and M. Crovella, "Changes in web client access patterns: Characteristics and caching implications", World Wide Web, vol. 2, pp. 15-28, DOI 10.1023/A:1019236319752, 1999.
Top   ToC   RFC7945 - Page 27
   [Bellissimo04]
              Bellissimo, A., Levine, B., and P. Shenoy, "Exploring the
              Use of BitTorrent as the Basis for a Large Trace
              Repository", University of Massachusetts Amherst, Tech.
              Rep. 04-41, 2004.

   [Bernardini14]
              Bernardini, C., et al., "Socially-aware caching strategy
              for content centric networking", Proc. IFIP Networking
              Conference, DOI 10.1109/IFIPNetworking.2014.6857093, 2014.

   [Blefari-Melazzi12]
              Blefari Melazzi, N., et al., "Scalability Measurements in
              an Information-Centric Network", Springer Lecture Notes in
              Computer Science (LNCS), vol. 7586,
              DOI 10.1007/978-3-642-41296-7_6, 2012.

   [Breslau99]
              Breslau, L., Cao, P., Fan, L., Phillips, G., and S.
              Shenker, "Web caching and zipf-like distributions:
              evidence and implications", Proc. of INFOCOM '99, New York
              (NY), USA, DOI 10.1109/INFCOM.1999.749260, March 1999.

   [Busari02] Busari, M. and C. Williamson, "ProWGen: a synthetic
              workload generation tool for simulation evaluation of web
              proxy caches", Computer Networks, vol. 38, no. 6, pp.
              779-794, DOI 10.1016/S1389-1286(01)00285-7, 2002.

   [Carofiglio11]
              Carofiglio, G., Gallo, M., Muscariello, L., and D. Perino,
              "Modeling Data Transfer in Content-Centric Networking",
              Proceedings of the 23rd International Teletraffic Congress
              (ITC '11), San Francisco, USA, September 2011.

   [Carofiglio13]
              Carofiglio, G., et al., "Optimal multipath congestion
              control and request forwarding in Information-Centric
              Networks", Proc. 2013 21st IEEE International Conference
              on Network Protocols (ICNP),
              DOI 10.1109/ICNP.2013.6733576, 2013.

   [CCNPL]    Institut de Recherche Technologique (IRT) SystemX, "CCNPL-
              SIM", <http://systemx.enst.fr/ccnpl-sim>.

   [ccnSim]   Rossini, G. and D. Rossi, "Large scale simulation of CCN
              networks", Proc. AlgoTel 2012, La Grande Motte, France,
              May 2012.
Top   ToC   RFC7945 - Page 28
   [Cha07]    Cha, M., Kwak, H., Rodriguez, P., Ahn, Y.-Y., and S. Moon,
              "I tube, you tube, everybody tubes: analyzing the world's
              largest user generated content video system", Proceedings
              of the 7th ACM SIGCOMM conference on Internet measurement
              (IMC '07), San Diego (CA), USA,
              DOI 10.1145/1298306.1298309, October 2007.

   [Chaabane13]
              Chaabane, A., De Cristofaro, E., Kaafar, M., and E. Uzun,
              "Privacy in Content-Oriented Networking: Threats and
              Countermeasures", ACM SIGCOMM Computer Communication
              Review, Vol. 43, Issue 3, DOI 10.1145/2500098.2500102,
              July 2013.

   [Cheng08]  Cheng, X., Dale, C., and J. Liu, "Statistics and social
              network of YouTube videos", 16th International Workshop on
              Quality of Service (IWQoS 2008), IEEE, pp. 229-238,
              DOI 10.1109/IWQOS.2008.32, 2008.

   [Cheng13]  Cheng, X., Liu, J., and C. Dale, "Understanding the
              Characteristics of Internet Short Video Sharing: YouTube
              as a Case Study", IEEE Transactions on Multimedia, vol.
              15, issue 5, DOI 10.1109/TMM.2013.2265531, 2013.

   [Chai12]   Chai, W., He, D., Psaras, I., and G. Pavlou, "Cache 'Less
              for More' in Information-centric Networks", Proceedings of
              the 11th international IFIP TC 6 conference on Networking
              (IFIP '12), DOI 10.1007/978-3-642-30045-5_3, 2012.

   [Cianci12] Cianci, I. et al. "CCN - Java Opensource Kit EmulatoR for
              Wireless Ad Hoc Networks", Proc. of the 7th International
              Conference on Future Internet Technologies (CFI '12),
              Seoul, Korea, DOI 10.1145/2377310.2377313, September 2012.

   [CMT-D5.2] Beben, A., et al., "Scalability of COMET System", COMET
              Project Deliverable D5.2, February 2013.

   [CMT-D6.2] Georgiades, M., et al., "Prototype Experimentation and
              Demonstration", COMET Project Deliverable D6.2, February
              2013.

   [Dannewitz10]
              Dannewitz, C., Golic, J., Ohlman, B., B. Ahlgren, "Secure
              Naming for A Network of Information", IEEE Conference on
              Computer Communications Workshops (INFOCOM), San Diego,
              CA, DOI 10.1109/INFCOMW.2010.5466661, March 2010.
Top   ToC   RFC7945 - Page 29
   [DETERLAB] Benzel, T., "The Science of Cyber-Security
              Experimentation: The DETER Project", Proceedings of the
              27th Annual Computer Security Applications Conference
              (ACSAC '11), DOI 10.1145/2076732.2076752, December 2011.

   [Dimitropoulos09]
              Dimitropoulos, X., et al., "Graph annotations in modeling
              complex network topologies", ACM Transactions on Modeling
              and Computer Simulation (TOMACS), vol. 19, no. 4,
              DOI 10.1145/1596519.1596522, November 2009.

   [DONA]     Koponen, T., et al., "A Data-Oriented (and Beyond) Network
              Architecture", Proceedings of the 2007 conference on
              Applications, technologies, architectures, and protocols
              for computer communications (SIGCOMM '07), ACM,
              DOI 10.1145/1282380.1282402, 2007.

   [EMULAB]   Eide, E., et al., "An Experimentation Workbench for
              Replayable Networking Research", Proceedings of the 4th
              USENIX conference on Networked systems design &
              implementation (NSDI '07), 2007.

   [Fotiou12] Fotiou, N., et al., "Access control enforcement delegation
              for information-centric networking architectures",
              Proceedings of the second edition of the ICN workshop on
              Information-centric networking (ICN '12), ACM,
              DOI 10.1145/2342488.2342507, 2012.

   [Fotiou14] Fotiou, N., et al., "A framework for privacy analysis of
              ICN architectures", Proc. Second Annual Privacy Forum
              (APF), Springer, DOI 10.1007/978-3-319-06749-0_8, 2014.

   [Fri12]    Fricker, C., Robert,  P., Roberts, J. and N. Sbihi,
              "Impact of traffic mix on caching performance in a
              content-centric network", 2012 IEEE Conference on Computer
              Communications Workshops (INFOCOM WKSHPS), Orlando, USA,
              DOI 10.1109/INFCOMW.2012.6193511, March 2012.

   [Goog08]   Google, "Official Google Blog: We knew the web was
              big...", July 2008, <http://googleblog.blogspot.it/
              2008/07/we-knew-web-was-big.html>.

   [Guo07]    Guo, L., Chen, S., Xiao, Z., Tan, E., Ding, X., and X.
              Zhang, "A performance study of BitTorrent-like peer-to-
              peer systems", IEEE Journal on Selected Areas in
              Communication, vol. 25, no. 1, pp. 155-169,
              DOI 10.1109/JSAC.2007.070116, 2007.
Top   ToC   RFC7945 - Page 30
   [HASHROUT] Saino, L., Psaras, I., and G. Pavlou, "Hash-routing
              Schemes for Information-Centric Networking", Proceedings
              of the 3rd ACM SIGCOMM workshop on Information-centric
              networking (ICN '13), DOI 10.1145/2491224.2491232, 2013.

   [Hefeeda08]
              Hefeeda, M. and O. Saleh, "Traffic Modeling and
              Proportional Partial Caching for Peer-to-Peer Systems",
              IEEE/ACM Transactions on Networking, vol. 16, no. 6, pp.
              1447-1460, DOI 10.1109/TNET.2008.918081, 2008.

   [ICARUS]   Saino, L., Psaras, I., and G. Pavlou, "Icarus: a Caching
              Simulator for Information Centric Networking (ICN)",
              Proceedings of the 7th International ICST Conference on
              Simulation Tools and Techniques (SimuTools '14),
              DOI 10.4108/icst.simutools.2014.254630, 2014.

   [Detti12]  Detti, A., et al., "Supporting the Web with an Information
              Centric Network that Routes by Name", Elsevier Computer
              Networks, vol. 56, no. 17,
              DOI 10.1016/j.comnet.2012.08.006, November 2012.

   [ICNSIMS]  Tortelli, M., et al., "CCN Simulators: Analysis and Cross-
              Comparison", Proceedings of the 1st international
              conference on Information-centric networking (ICN '14),
              ACM, DOI 10.1145/2660129.2660133, 2014.

   [IMB2014]  Imbrenda, C., Muscariello, L., and D. Rossi, "Analyzing
              Cacheable Traffic in ISP Access Networks for Micro CDN
              Applications via Content-Centric Networking", Proceedings
              of the 1st international conference on Information-centric
              networking (ICN '14), DOI 10.1145/2660129.2660146, 2014.

   [Ion13]    Ion, M., Zhang, J., and E. Schooler, "Toward content-
              centric privacy in ICN: attribute-based encryption and
              routing", Proceedings of the ACM SIGCOMM 2013 conference
              on SIGCOMM (SIGCOMM '13), ACM,
              DOI 10.1145/2486001.2491717, 2013.

   [Jacobson09]
              Jacobson, V., et al., "Networking Named Content",
              Proceedings of the 5th international conference on
              Emerging networking experiments and technologies (CoNEXT
              '09), DOI 10.1145/1658939.1658941, 2009.
Top   ToC   RFC7945 - Page 31
   [Katsaros12]
              Katsaros, K., Xylomenos, G., and G. Polyzos, "GlobeTraff:
              a traffic workload generator for the performance
              evaluation of future Internet architectures", 2012 5th
              International Conference on New Technologies, Mobility and
              Security (NTMS), DOI 10.1109/NTMS.2012.6208742, 2012.

   [Katsaros15]
              Katsaros, K., et al., "On the Inter-domain Scalability of
              Route-by-Name Information-Centric Network Architectures",
              Proc. IFIP Networking Conference,
              DOI 10.1109/IFIPNetworking.2015.7145308, 2015.

   [Kaune09]  Kaune, S. et al., "Modelling the Internet Delay Space
              Based on Geographical Locations", 17th Euromicro
              International Conference on Parallel, Distributed and
              Network-based Processing, Weimar, Germany,
              DOI 10.1109/PDP.2009.44, 2009.

   [Labovitz10]
              Labovitz, C., Iekel-Johnson, S., McPherson, D., Oberheide,
              J., and F. Jahanian, "Internet inter-domain traffic", In
              Proceedings of the ACM SIGCOMM 2010 conference (SIGCOMM
              DOI 10.1145/1851182.1851194, 2010.

   [Lauinger10]
              Lauinger, T., "Security and Scalability of Content-Centric
              Networking", Masters Thesis, Technische Universitaet
              Darmstadt and Eurecom, September 2010.

   [Lauinger12]
              Lauinger, Y., et al, "Privacy Risks in Named Data
              Networking: What is the Cost of Performance?", ACM SIGCOMM
              Computer Communication Review, Vol. 42, Issue 5,
              DOI 10.1145/2378956.2378966, 2012.

   [Led12]    Lederer, S., Muller, C., and C. Timmerer, "Dynamic
              adaptive streaming over HTTP dataset", Proceedings of the
              ACM Multimedia Systems Conference (MMSys '12), pp. 89-94,
              DOI 10.1145/2155555.2155570, 2012.

   [Lewko11]  Lewko, A. and B. Waters, "Decentralizing attribute-based
              encryption", Proc. of EUROCRYPT 2011, Lecture Notes in
              Computer Science (LNCS), vol. 6632, pp. 568-588,
              DOI 10.1007/978-3-642-20465-4_31, 2011.
Top   ToC   RFC7945 - Page 32
   [LIRA]     Psaras, I., Katsaros, K., Saino, L., and G. Pavlou, "Lira:
              A location independent routing layer based on source-
              provided ephemeral names", Electronic and Electrical Eng.
              Dept., UCL, London, UK, Tech. Rep. 2014,
              <http://www.ee.ucl.ac.uk/comit-project/publications.html>.

   [Mahanti00]
              Mahanti, A., Williamson, C., and D. Eager., "Traffic
              analysis of a web proxy caching hierarchy", IEEE Network,
              Vol. 14, No. 3, pp. 16-23, DOI 10.1109/65.844496, May/June
              2000.

   [Maier09]  Maier, G., Feldmann, A., Paxson, V., and M. Allman, "On
              dominant characteristics of residential broadband internet
              traffic", In Proceedings of the 9th ACM SIGCOMM conference
              on Internet measurement conference (IMC '09), New York,
              NY, USA, 90-102. DOI 10.1145/1644893.1644904, 2009.

   [Marciniak08]
              Marciniak, P., Liogkas, N., Legout, A., and E. Kohler,
              "Small is not always beautiful",  In Proc. of IPTPS,
              International Workshop of Peer-to-Peer Systems, Tampa Bay,
              Florida (FL), USA, February 2008.

   [MiniCCNx] Cabral, C., et al., "High fidelity content-centric
              experiments with Mini-CCNx", 2014 IEEE Symposium on
              Computers and Communications (ISCC),
              DOI 10.1109/ISCC.2014.6912537, 2014.

   [Montage]  Hussain, A. and J. Chen, "Montage Topology Manager: Tools
              for Constructing and Sharing Representative Internet
              Topologies", DETER Technical Report, ISI-TR-684, August
              2012.

   [Muscariello11]
              Muscariello, L., Carofiglio, G., and M. Gallo, "Bandwidth
              and storage sharing performance in information centric
              networking", Proceedings of the ACM SIGCOMM workshop on
              Information-centric networking (ICN '11),
              DOI 10.1145/2018584.2018593, 2011.

   [ndnSIM]   Afanasyev, A., et al., "ndnSIM: NDN simulator for NS-3",
              NDN Technical Report NDN-0005, Revision 2, October 2012.

   [ndnSIM2]  Mastorakis, S., et al., "ndnSIM 2.0: A new version of the
              NDN simulator for NS-3", NDN Technical Report NDN-0028,
              Revision 1, January 2015.
Top   ToC   RFC7945 - Page 33
   [NEPI]     Quereilhac, A., et al., "NEPI: An integration framework
              for Network Experimentation", 2011 19th International
              Conference on Software, Telecommunications and Computer
              Networks (SoftCOM), IEEE, 2011.

   [OFELIA]   Sune, M., et al., "Design and implementation of the OFELIA
              FP7 facility: The European OpenFlow testbed", Computer
              Networks, vol. 61, pp. 132-150,
              DOI 10.1016/j.bjp.2013.10.015, March 2014.

   [ONL]      DeHart, J., et al., "The open network laboratory: a
              resource for networking research and education", ACM
              SIGCOMM Computer Communication Review (CCR), vol. 35, no.
              5, pp. 75-78, DOI 10.1145/1096536.1096547, 2005.

   [Parisis13]
              Parisis, G., Trossen, D., and H. Asaeda, "A Node Design
              and a Framework for Development and Experimentation for an
              Information-Centric Network", IEICE Transactions on
              Communications, vol. E96-B, no. 7, pp. 1650-1660, July
              2013.

   [Perino11] Perino, D. and M. Varvello, "A Reality Check for Content
              Centric Networking", Proceedings of the ACM SIGCOMM
              workshop on Information-centric networking (ICN '11),
              DOI 10.1145/2018584.2018596, 2011.

   [PLANETLAB]
              Chun, B., et al., "Planetlab: an overlay testbed for
              broad-coverage services", ACM SIGCOMM Computer
              Communication Review (CCR), vol. 33, no. 3, pp. 3-12,
              DOI 10.1145/956993.956995, 2003.

   [PRST4.5]  Riihijarvi, J., et al., "Final Architecture Validation and
              Performance Evaluation Report", PURSUIT Project
              Deliverable D4.5, January 2013.

   [Psaras11] Psaras, I., Clegg, R., Landa, R., Chai, W., Pavlou, G.,
              "Modelling and Evaluation of CCN-Caching Trees",
              Proceedings of the 10th international IFIP TC 6 conference
              on Networking, Valencia, Spain, May 2011.

   [Psaras12] Psaras, I., Chai, W., and G. Pavlou, "Probabilistic In-
              Network Caching for Information-Centric Networks",
              Proceedings of the second edition of the ICN workshop on
              Information-centric networking (ICN '12),
              DOI 10.1145/2342488.2342501, 2012.
Top   ToC   RFC7945 - Page 34
   [Quereilhac14]
              Quereilhac, A., et al., "Demonstrating a unified ICN
              development and evaluation framework", Proceedings of the
              1st international conference on Information-centric
              networking (ICN '14), ACM, DOI 10.1145/2660129.2660132,
              2014.

   [Renault09]
              Renault, E., Ahmad, A., and M. Abid, "Toward a Security
              Model for the Future Network of Information", Proceedings
              of the 4th International Conference on Ubiquitous
              Information Technologies & Applications (ICUT '09), IEEE,
              DOI 10.1109/ICUT.2009.5405676, 2009.

   [RFC2330]  Paxson, V., Almes, G., Mahdavi, J., and M. Mathis,
              "Framework for IP Performance Metrics", RFC 2330,
              DOI 10.17487/RFC2330, May 1998,
              <http://www.rfc-editor.org/info/rfc2330>.

   [RFC5743]  Falk, A., "Definition of an Internet Research Task Force
              (IRTF) Document Stream", RFC 5743, DOI 10.17487/RFC5743,
              December 2009, <http://www.rfc-editor.org/info/rfc5743>.

   [RFC6920]  Farrell, S., Kutscher, D., Dannewitz, C., Ohlman, B.,
              Keranen, A., and P. Hallam-Baker, "Naming Things with
              Hashes", RFC 6920, DOI 10.17487/RFC6920, April 2013,
              <http://www.rfc-editor.org/info/rfc6920>.

   [RFC7476]  Pentikousis, K., Ed., Ohlman, B., Corujo, D., Boggia, G.,
              Tyson, G., Davies, E., Molinaro, A., and S. Eum,
              "Information-Centric Networking: Baseline Scenarios",
              RFC 7476, DOI 10.17487/RFC7476, March 2015,
              <http://www.rfc-editor.org/info/rfc7476>.

   [RFC7927]  Kutscher, D., Ed., Eum, S., Pentikousis, K., Psaras, I.,
              Corujo, D., Saucez, D., Schmidt, T., and M. Waehlisch,
              "Information-Centric Networking (ICN) Research
              Challenges", RFC 7927, DOI 10.17487/RFC7927, July 2016,
              <http://www.rfc-editor.org/info/rfc7927>.

   [RFC7933]  Westphal, C., Ed., Lederer, S., Posch, D., Timmerer, C.,
              Azgin, A., Liu, W., Mueller, C., Detti, A., Corujo, D.,
              Wang, J., Montpetit, M., and N. Murray, "Adaptive Video
              Streaming over Information-Centric Networking (ICN)",
              RFC 7933, DOI 10.17487/RFC7933, August 2016,
              <http://www.rfc-editor.org/info/rfc7933>.
Top   ToC   RFC7945 - Page 35
   [SAIL-B2]  SAIL, "NetInf Content Delivery and Operations", SAIL
              Project Deliverable D-B.2, May 2012.

   [SAIL-B3]  Kutscher, D., Ed., et al., "Final NetInf Architecture",
              SAIL Project Deliverable D-B.3, January 2013,
              <http://www.sail-project.eu/deliverables/>.

   [Saino13]  Saino, L., Cocora, C., and G. Pavlou, "A Toolchain for
              Simplifying Network Simulation Setup", Proceedings of the
              6th International ICST Conference on Simulation Tools and
              Techniques (SimuTools '13), 2013.

   [Saleh06]  Saleh, O., and M. Hefeeda, "Modeling and caching of peer-
              to-peer traffic", Proceedings of the 2006 IEEE
              International Conference on Network Protocols (ICNP),
              DOI 10.1109/ICNP.2006.320218, 2006.

   [Salsano12]
              Salsano, S., et al., "Transport-Layer Issues in
              Information Centric Networks", Proceedings of the second
              edition of the ICN workshop on Information-centric
              networking (ICN '12), ACM, DOI 10.1145/2342488.2342493,
              2012.

   [Salsano13]
              Salsano, S., et al., "Information Centric Networking over
              SDN and OpenFlow: Architectural Aspects and Experiments on
              the OFELIA Testbed", Computer Networks, vol. 57, no. 16,
              pp. 3207-3221, DOI 10.1016/j.comnet.2013.07.031, November
              2013.

   [SensReqs] Karnouskos, S., et al., "Requirement considerations for
              ubiquitous integration of cooperating objects", 2011 4th
              IFIP International Conference on New Technologies,
              Mobility and Security (NTMS),
              DOI 10.1109/NTMS.2011.5720605, 2011.

   [Smetters09]
              Smetters, D., and V. Jacobson, "Securing network content",
              Technical Report TR-2009-01, PARC, 2009.

   [Sourlas15]
              Sourlas, V., Tassiulas, L., Psaras, I., and G. Pavlou,
              "Information Resilience through User-Assisted Caching in
              Disruptive Content-Centric Networks", 14th IFIP Networking
              Conference, Toulouse, France,
              DOI 10.1109/IFIPNetworking.2015.7145301, May 2015.
Top   ToC   RFC7945 - Page 36
   [Tagger12] Tagger, B., et al., "Update on the Architecture and Report
              on Security Analysis", Deliverable 2.4, PURSUIT EU FP7
              project, April 2012.

   [Tourani16]
              Tourani, R., Mick, T., Misra, S., and G. Panwar,
              "Security, Privacy, and Access Control in Information-
              Centric Networking: A Survey", arXiv:1603.03409, March
              2016.

   [VoCCN]    Jacobson, V., et al., "VoCCN: Voice-over Content-Centric
              Networks", Proceedings of the 2009 workshop on Re-
              architecting the internet (ReArch '09),
              DOI 10.1145/1658978.1658980, 2009.

   [Watts98]  Watts, D. J. and S. H. Strogatz, "Collective dynamics of
              'small-world' networks", Nature, vol. 393, no. 6684, pp.
              440-442, DOI 10.1038/30918, April 1998.

   [Yu06]     Yu, H., Zheng, D., Zhao, B., and W. Zheng, "Understanding
              user behavior in large-scale video-on-demand systems", ACM
              SIGOPS Operating Systems Review - Proceedings of the 2006
              EuroSys conference, Vol. 40, Issue 4, pp. 333-344,
              DOI 10.1145/1218063.1217968, April 2006.

   [Zhang10a] Zhang, C., Dhungel, P., Wu, D., and K. Ross, "Unraveling
              the BitTorrent Ecosystem", IEEE Transactions on Parallel
              and Distributed Systems, vol. 22, issue 7, pp. 1164-1177,
              DOI 10.1109/TPDS.2010.123, 2010.

   [Zhang10b] Zhang, L., et al., "Named Data Networking (NDN) Project",
              NDN Technical Report NDN-0001, October 2010,
              <http://named-data.net/publications/techreports/>.

   [Zhou11]   Zhou, J., Li,  Y., Adhikari, K., and Z.-L. Zhang,
              "Counting YouTube videos via random prefix sampling",
              Proceedings of the 2011 ACM SIGCOMM conference on Internet
              measurement conference (IMC '11), Berlin, Germany,
              DOI 10.1145/2068816.2068851, November 2011.
Top   ToC   RFC7945 - Page 37

Acknowledgments

Konstantinos Katsaros contributed the updated text of Section 2.2 along with an extensive set of references. Priya Mahadevan, Daniel Corujo, and Gareth Tyson contributed to a draft version of this document. This document has benefited from reviews, pointers to the growing ICN literature, suggestions, comments, and proposed text provided by the following members of the IRTF Information-Centric Networking Research Group (ICNRG), listed in alphabetical order: Marica Amadeo, Hitoshi Asaeda, E. Baccelli, Claudia Campolo, Christian Esteve Rothenberg, Suyong Eum, Nikos Fotiou, Dorothy Gellert, Luigi Alfredo Grieco, Myeong-Wuk Jang, Ren Jing, Will Liu, Antonella Molinaro, Luca Muscariello, Ioannis Psaras, Dario Rossi, Stefano Salsano, Damien Saucez, Dirk Trossen, Jianping Wang, Yuanzhe Xuan, and Xinwen Zhang. The IRSG review was provided by Aaron Falk.
Top   ToC   RFC7945 - Page 38

Authors' Addresses

Kostas Pentikousis (editor) Travelping Koernerstr. 7-10 10785 Berlin Germany Email: k.pentikousis@travelping.com Borje Ohlman Ericsson Research S-16480 Stockholm Sweden Email: Borje.Ohlman@ericsson.com Elwyn Davies Trinity College Dublin/Folly Consulting Ltd Dublin, 2 Ireland Email: davieseb@scss.tcd.ie Spiros Spirou Intracom Telecom 19.7 km Markopoulou Avenue 19002 Peania, Athens Greece Email: spis@intracom-telecom.com Gennaro Boggia Dept. of Electrical and Information Engineering Politecnico di Bari Via Orabona 4 70125 Bari Italy Email: g.boggia@poliba.it