tech-invite   World Map     

IETF     RFCs     Groups     SIP     ABNFs    |    3GPP     Specs     Gloss.     Arch.     IMS     UICC    |    Misc.    |    search     info

RFC 0076

Pages: 15
Top     in Index     Prev     Next

Connection by name: User oriented protocol


Top       Page 1 
Network Working Group                                      J. Bouknight
Request for Comments: 76                                      J. Madden
NIC 5180                                                    G. Grossman
                                                 University of Illinois
                                                        28 October 1970

               Connection-By-Name: User-Oriented Protocol

I. Introduction

   Shortly after the first of the year, 1971, the Center for Advanced
   Computation (CAC) at the University of Illinois will begin to use the
   facilities of the ARPA network.  We are the first of a small class of
   network nodes whose chief characteristic is that the node is a port
   to the network only.  All computational power for these nodes will be
   taken from other nodes on the network, ILLIAC IV for example.

   An important characteristic of most of the users at our Center is a
   lack of sophistication about data communication techniques and
   practices.  The user will eventually be in the majority of those
   using the network from all nodes but the problem is ours, almost from
   the start.

   In our discussions with our prospective users of the network as we
   designed our port facility, we found that the greatest confusion and
   consternation arose over having to deal with network protocol at the
   "nitty-gritty" level of sockets, links, etc.  While most of them have
   been acclimated to computer systems at the file and device-by-name
   level where the software system handles details, here on the current
   version of the network, the user handles all details.

   Thus, we were compelled to seek a user level interface to network
   protocol where all user protocol is handled symbolically with system
   procedures making the translation into host-to-host protocol.

   Currently, connections are established by exchange of known socket
   numbers for the four loose ends of the connection.  This requires
   either that the user or process always know all socket numbers he
   will use at his or other installations OR that his NCP (and/or
   related software) remember them for him, allowing him to reference
   them symbolically.

   We propose a more general solution to the "telephone book" approach
   of obtaining socket numbers for user or processes.  Only the host, at
   each site, knows its socket number space at any given instant in time
   as well as the status of the user or process to which a socket number

Top       Page 2 
   assigned.  Additionally, most permanently assigned devices and/or
   processes are known by standard mnemonic labels such as DSK (disk),
   LP (line printer), CR (card reader), TECO (PDP-10 text editor), etc.
   In most systems, all other communications are done through files or
   pseudo files, known only to the user by their names and not by their
   internal mechanism.  In other words, most intrasystem communication
   at the user level is by symbolic reference to both devices and

   We propose facilities, by extension of the current protocol, that
   will allow users to use the network on a connection-by-name basis as
   they already do in their host system.  In the remainder of this paper
   we will present the suggested extensions to the current protocol and
   give an example of its usage in a dialogue between a user at CAC,
   controlling two processes; one at UTAH, and one at PAOLI (ILLIAC IV
   construction site).

II. Proposed Extensions to Protocol

   Let us define a class of syntax elements for use in our proposed
   extensions to the protocol. (This syntax is expressed in the
   metalanguage of the ALGOL-60 report.)

   <label> ::= <usercode>/<filename>|<device name>

   <devicename> ::= <string>

   <usercode> ::= <string>

   <filename> ::= <string>|<filename>/<string>

   <string> ::= <char>|<char> <string>

   <char> ::= A|B|C|D|E|F|G|H|I|J|K|L|M|N|O|P|Q|R|S|T|U|V|W|X|Y|Z|0|1|2|

   A standard set of <devicenames> should be established to reference
   line printers, card readers, etc. - those hard peripherals with fixed
   processing tasks.  A beginning set of <labels> might be:

      LP            line printer
      CR            card reader
      CP            card punch
      PTR           paper tape recorder
      PTP           paper tape punch
      MT            magnetic tape
      DSK           disk
      TTY           teletype compatible terminal

Top       Page 3 
   The format of <usercode> is that of the responding host for the
   current discussion.  Future discussions about foreign-user usage of
   host facilities may result in a standard format for the entire

   Most systems can identify files by one <string> plus the <usercode>.
   Others, such as the Burroughs B6500 use multifile identifiers where
   many <strings> may be used in the <label>.  The set of <char> is that
   proposed in RFC 66, i.e., ASCII.

   The proposed extensions involve a "request" for information and
   several variants of a "response" to the request.

   A. Request for Socket Number for this Label

      <RFSNL> <my socker #> <0> <label>

   The RFSNL is sent on the control link to the destination host
   requesting the socket number of the attached <label>.

   B. Acknowledgement of Request

   Upon receipt of an <RFSNL>, the destination host returns one of three

      <AORP> <desired socket#> <your socket #>

      <AORN> <desired socket#> <your socket #>

      <AORN> <0> <your socket #>

   The first response returns the requested socket number and signifies
   that the user, device, or process exists.  The second response
   returns the requested socket number but signifies that the user,
   device, or process is not currently available for connection.  The
   last response signifies that no such user, device, or process exists.

   C. Discussion

   The above extensions to the protocol are intended to enhance user
   acclimation to network usage.  The element of strangeness is subdued
   and, in fact, for user of the B6500 erased.  Attached to this RFC is
   an appendix containing a preliminary description of the user language
   of the network port facility being brought up at the CAC.  We now
   present a sample user session on the CAC facility and detail how the
   protocol is used to establish the proper communication paths.

Top       Page 4 
III. Example of User Dialogue

   Assume a user residing at CAC, whose site code is URBANA.  His
   terminal is an alphanumeric CRT terminal and we assume solution of
   code conversion problems for network communications.

   The sample user session will involve the setting up of two processes
   at two host sites with control from the third host site.  All
   operations can be accomplished with the current protocol plus the
   proposed extensions.

   In addition, we also assume that some form of standard user code is
   in use for all host sites uniquely identifying every network user
   when he is present.

   Output keyed by systems will be underlined.  Comments are offset to
   the right for legibility.  All statements about the UTAH system are
   purely hypothetical.

    User Dialogue                           Comments

                                 The user moves to the terminal, applies
                                 power and types:

                                 The CAC system responds for login
                                 purposes with:

                                 for the user's code.

                                 This acknowledges proper usercode and
                                 sends any appropriate notes on system
                                 The exclamation point (!) is the escape
                                 character which flags direct input to
                                 the PDP-11 OS:

                                 User requests connection to the ILLIAC
                                 IV node.  NCP operations establish link
                                 from user terminal to B6500 MCP.

Top       Page 5 
                                 Completes response.


                                 1. DISK/PRINT lists text files from
                                 disk to B6500 line printer.
                                 2. REMOTE files on the B6500 will refer
                                 to files going to/coming from the
                                 3. ALPHA@UTAH specifies that a
                                 connection is to be made via the
                                 network to a file GROSSMAN/ALPHA from
                                 the UTAH node.
                                 4. QUEUE specifies periodic attempt to
                                 complete the connection.

                                 The B6500 will ask for the socket
                                 number associated with GROSSMAN/ALPHA
                                 until an AORP is received.

                                 The language is that of the monitor for
                                 the B6500
                                 All data received or sent on the link
                                 to ILLIAC must now be prefaced by the #


                                 User now links into UTAH PDP-10 system.

   #1410: DISK/PRINT BOJ 1441
                                 System message stating beginning-of-job
                                 for DISK/PRINT on B6500.


    . R PIP
                                 User will run PIP on a listing file.

Top       Page 6 
                                 NETWRK is network file type for UTAH
                                 system.  Mechanism for file control
                                 basically same as for B6500 system.
                                 Since PIP will be sending to the
                                 network, it does not request a socket #
                                 from the B6500 NCP but instead
                                 instructs its NCP to acknowledge any
                                 request for GROSSMAN/ALPHA from ILLIAC
                                 with the socket number PIP will send
                                 from.  As soon as the B6500 NCP tries
                                 again to find GROSSMAN/ALPHA from UTAH,
                                 success occurs and the socket numbers
                                 are exchanged with subsequent
                                 connection establishment.

                                 PIP completes the task and terminates
                                 the connection to the B6500.

   #14: DISK/PRINT EOJ 1448
                                 B6500 acknowledges completion of task.

                                 User sends message to B6500 operator.

                                 User logs out of UTAH.

                                 System logout listing.


                                 Link to UTAH system now dropped.

                                 B6500 operator response.

Top       Page 7 
   ! LEAVE
                                 User desired to log out of CAC system.

                                 Link to ILLIAC system new dropped.

                                 Session over.

Top       Page 8 
        Syntax and Semantics for the Terminal User Control Language
           for the Proposed PDP-11 ARPA Network Terminal System


                              G. R. Grossman

Prefatory Notes

   The following document represents a first attempt at providing a
   control language for the terminal user of the PDP-11 network terminal
   system.  This language is deemed sufficiently powerful to provide the
   user with a minimal facility for attaching to remote host computers
   over the ARPA network, initiating processes, and routing data flow to
   local peripheral devices.

   The hardware system as envisioned will comprise a PDP-11/20 with a
   least 8k of core, a small disk (512 kilobytes of storage), a console
   teletype, and optional card readers, line printers, DECtapes, User
   terminals, card punches, storage scopes, etc.

   The executive system will consist of a basic driver system which will
   control autonomous processes and interrupt-driven device service
   routines.  The system will keep tables in core and on the small disk
   for logging peripheral usage, keeping track of connections on the
   network, queuing up of tasks that cannot be immediately performed,
   storing attributes of remote hosts, etc.

   Since network hosts handle communications in character-at-a-time or
   message modes, and may or may not echo characters over the network,
   the system takes this into account when handling connections to
   specific hosts.  If the connection is in message mode, minimal line-
   by-line editing facility (character and line deletion) is provided.

   A means for the user to change flag and message transmit characters
   is provided to prevent incompatibilities which may arise between the
   PDP-11 and other hosts.

   This document does not describe control card syntax for card reader
   usage, nor does it describe the operator's control language.  These
   will be described in later documents.

Character Set

   <character> ::= <letter> | <digit> | <special> | <space>

   <letter>    ::= A | B | ... | Y | Z

Top       Page 9 
   <digit>     ::= 0 | 1 | ... | 8 | 9

   <special>   ::= ! | " | # | $ | % | & | ' | ( | ) | * | + | , | - |
                   . | / | : | : | < | = | > | ? | @ | [ |  | ] | ^ |
                     |` | { | <bar> | }


   <identifiers> ::= <letter> | <identifier> <letter> |
                     <identifier> <digit>

        Semantics:  Identifiers are used to designate peripheral units,
        host computers, etc.  No identifier may exceed 8 characters in


   <integer> ::= <digit> | <integer> <digit>

        Semantics:  <integer> are the only form of number allowed in the
        control language.  They must not exceed 2^15-1.

Peripheral Designator

   <peripheral designator> ::= <device class> <device number> | OPR

   <device number>         ::= <digit> | <digit> <digit> |

   <device class>          ::= CR | CP | LP | DT | TR | SS

        Semantics:  Peripheral designators name specific peripheral
        devices.  Device lasses designate classes of peripherals.

        OPR designates the operator's console teletype.  The classes of
        peripherals corresponding to the device classes are given on the
        following table:

            <device class>                      type of peripheral

                CR                                  card reader
                CP                                  card punch
                LP                                  line printer
                DT                                  DECtape
                TR                                  terminal
                SS                                  storage scope

Top       Page 10 
File Label

   <file label>     ::=  <tape label> |  <tape label> / <tape file name>

   <tape label>     ::=  <identifier>

   <tape file name> ::=  <identifier>

        Semantics: File labels provide the means for designating tape
        files symbolically.  If the <tape label> form is used, the
        designated file is assumed to occupy the entire tape.

Flagged Control Statement

   <flagged control statement>  ::= <flag> <control statement>

   <flag>                       ::= <special>

        Semantics: <Flagged control statement>s arc the user's names of
        communicating with the PDP-11 system.  The <flag> must be the
        system default flag (!) or a substitute which the user provides
        by means of the <flag statement>.  Input to the system which
        does not begin with a <flag> will be passed on to the process to
        which the user is connected, if any.

Control Statements

   <control statement>  ::= <link statement> |

                            <copy statement> |

                            <end statement> |

                            <user statement> |

                            <status statement> |

                            <out statement> |

                            <to statement> |

                            <escape statement> |

                            <back statement> |

                            <delete statement> |

                            <transmit statement> |

Top       Page 11 
                            <lock statement> |

                            <unlock statement> |

                            <assign statement> |

                            <label statement> |

                            <create statement> |

Link Statement

   <link statement> ::= LINK TO <host> <q>

   <q>              ::= <empty> |

                        QUEUE   |

                        QUEUE    <integer>

        Semantics: The Link statement directs the system to set up a
        connection between the user's unit and a remote host.  The <q>
        construct allows the user to specify that, if the connection
        cannot be set up immediately, the system is to keep trying.  If
        the QUEUE form is used, the system will keep trying
        indefinitely.  If the QUEUE integer form is used, the system
        will try for integer minutes.

Copy Statement

   <copy statement>   ::= COPY <source> TO <dest> <q>

   <source>           ::= NETWORK |

                          <file label> |

                          <source class> |

                          <source device>

   <source class>     ::= CR | TR | SS |

   <source device>    ::= <source class> <device number>

   <dest>             ::= NETWORK

                          <file label> |

Top       Page 12 
                          <dest class> |

                          <dest device>

   <dest class>       ::= CP | LP | TR | SS

   <dest device>      ::= <dest class> <device number>

        Semantics: The <copy statement> directs the system to set up a
        connection between the <source> and <dest> and copy records of
        information between them.  If the <device class> or <device>
        form is used for either <source> or <dest>, the copy process
        cannot begin until a unit is assigned to the user.  If the <file
        label> form is used, the copy process can likewise not proceed
        until the system has access to a properly labeled tape. if the
        NETWORK form is used, a connection to a remote process must be

        The <q> construct has the same meaning as for the <link
        statement>, with the additional provision that the condition
        that caused the process to be incomplete may be the lack of a
        device assignment.

End Statement

   <end statement>   ::= END

        Semantics: The <end statement> causes the current connection to
        be terminated.

User Statement

   <user statement>  ::= USER = <identifier>

        Semantics: The <user statement> is used during the log in
        process to allow the user to identify himself.

Status Statement

   <status statement> ::= STATUS <device class> |

                          STATUS <peripheral designator>

        Semantics: The <status statement> allows the user to interrogate
        the system as to the status of a device or class of devices.

Top       Page 13 
Out Statement

   <out statement> ::= OUT|LEAVE

        Semantics: The <out statement> allows a user to log out of the
        system.  If the OUT form is used, all queued process initiated
        by the user are terminated.  The LEAVE from does not terminate
        such pending queued processes so long as these processes do not
        directly involve the user's terminal.

To Statement

   <to statement> ::= TO CON :<text> |  TO <user> : <text>

        Semantics: The <to statement> allows the user to send a message
        to the operator or another logged-in user.

Flag Statement

   <flag statement> ::= FLAG = <special>

        Semantics: The <flag statement> allows the user to define the
        character which the system recognizes as preceding a control
        statement as distinguished from a message to a remote process to
        which he may be attached.  The default flag character is "|".

Back Statement

   <back statement> ::= BACK ? {ascii special or control character}

        Semantics: The <back statement> allows the user to define the
        character which, in control or message mode, causes the system
        to "forget" the previous input character.  The default backspace
        character is RUBOUT (ASCII 1778).

Delete Statement

   <delete statement> ::= DELETE = {ASCII special or control character}

        Semantics: The <delete statement> allows the user to define the
        character which, in control or message mode, causes the system
        to "forget" the previous line of input.  The default delete
        character is ASCII VT (control K).

Top       Page 14 
Transmit Statement

   <transmit statement> ::= TRANSMIT = {ASCII special or
                                        control character}

        Semantics: The <transmit statement> allows the user to define
        the character which, in control or message mode, causes the
        system to begin interpreting the control statement or to
        transmit the message.  The default transmit character is
        carriage return.

Lock Statement

   <lock statement> ::= LOCK

        Semantics: The <lock statement> causes the system to prevent any
        user or process but the process to which the user is currently
        attached from sending messages to the user's terminal.

Unlock Statement

   <unlock statement> ::= UNLOCK

        Semantics: The <unlock statement> reverses the action of a
        previous <lock statement>.

Assign Statement

   <assign statement> ::= ASSIGN <assign device> <q>

   <assign device>    ::= LP | DT | CP

        Semantics: The <assign statement> causes the system to attempt
        to assign a device not currently in use to the user.  The <q>
        construct has the same meaning as for the <link statement>.

Label Statement

   <label statement> ::? LABEL DT <device number> <tape label>

        Semantics: The <label statement> causes the system to write a
        new label on the DEC tape specified.

Top       Page 15 
Create Statement

   <create statement> ::= CREATE <tape file name> ON <tape label>

        Semantics: The <create statement> causes the system to create a
        new file named <tape file name> on the DEC tape labeled <tape

Purge Statement

   <purge statement> ::= PURGE <tape label> |

                         PURGE <tape file name> ON <tape label>

        Semantics: The <purge statement> causes the system to delete all
        tape directory information on the DEC tape or tape file

           [ This RFC was put into machine readable form for entry ]
            [ into the online RFC archives by Gottfried Janik 2/98 ]